Pair comparison · research hypothesis
歩く都市と、動けない部屋
The Walking City and the Immobile Room
身体が移動できる範囲は、観測される世界の範囲をどのように変えるのか。
How does the range of the body change the range of the observed world?
Hypothesis table
| 永井荷風 | 正岡子規 | Status | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Observation space観測空間 | 都市・街路 | 病床・室内 | HYPOTHESIS · not-indexed |
| Mobility移動 | 徒歩移動 | 身体的制約 | HYPOTHESIS · not-indexed |
| External world外部世界 | 直接的な都市体験 | 来訪者・新聞・手紙など | HYPOTHESIS · not-indexed |
| Bodily experience身体経験 | 移動する身体 | 制約された身体 | HYPOTHESIS · not-indexed |
| Daily record日々の記録 | 都市生活の記録 | 病床生活の記録 | HYPOTHESIS · not-indexed |
- This table is a research hypothesis from the brief. No frequency or content claim has been tested.
- The works differ in form: 断腸亭日乗 and 仰臥漫録 are diary-like records; 病牀六尺 and 墨汁一滴 are newspaper-serialized essays written for readers.
- Kafū's coverage is 1917–1921 only; Shiki's works fall in a different period (dates unverified). Any comparison mixes period, form, and body.
- Writing conventions and source completeness differ; rates are not comparable without matching coverage and review.
Synthetic experiment · SYN-SHIKI-001
SYNTHETIC — not historical evidence. Synthetic fixtures written for this test, dated in the fictional year 2101. Results describe the instrument, not Nagai Kafū or Masaoka Shiki. Differences between conditions exist because the fixtures were written that way.
- Evidence traceability
- 100.0%
- Observation coverage (A / B)
- 89.0% / 89.0%
- Classification consistency
- 100.0%
- Uncertainty preserved
- true
- Comparison reproducible
- true
- Reviewer agreement
- NOT_APPLICABLE
| Category (synthetic) | A · Urban Mobility | B · Bodily Constraint |
|---|---|---|
| walking | 84.3% (273/324; entry-dated 273) | 4.9% (16/324; entry-dated 0) |
| visitors | 0.0% (0/324; entry-dated 0) | 25.0% (81/324; entry-dated 81) |
| newspaper | 5.9% (19/324; entry-dated 19) | 18.8% (61/324; entry-dated 61) |
| food | 50.0% (162/324; entry-dated 162) | 72.5% (235/324; entry-dated 235) |
| body | 0.0% (0/324; entry-dated 0) | 18.8% (61/324; entry-dated 61) |
| pain | 0.0% (0/324; entry-dated 0) | 18.8% (61/324; entry-dated 61) |
| garden | 0.0% (0/324; entry-dated 0) | 51.2% (166/324; entry-dated 154) |
| weather | 44.1% (143/324; entry-dated 143) | 47.5% (154/324; entry-dated 154) |
Rates differ because the synthetic text was written differently. They say nothing about Kafū or Shiki.
Q1. 身体的移動の制約によって観測対象は変化するか。
Instrument check: The instrument registers a lower walking-reference rate and a higher visit/newspaper rate in condition B, as constructed. B's walking references are all recollections: none is dated to the entry, so a mention is not counted as movement.
Historical answer: NOT_ANSWERED
Q2. 移動しない身体は、外部世界との接続をどのように記録するか。
Instrument check: Visits are proposed as REPORTED_EVENT (another person's action) and newspapers as mentions; channels are separable for review.
Historical answer: NOT_ANSWERED
Q3. 食事、介護、来訪者などの生活維持活動は、日記の中でどのように現れるか。
Instrument check: Meals and visits are counted; care itself has no dictionary rule yet and is not measured.
Historical answer: NOT_ANSWERED
Q4. 都市を歩く人物と病床にいる人物では、時間や空間の表現にどのような差異が現れるか。
Instrument check: Retrospective and future references are kept off the entry date; spatial expressions beyond the dictionary are not measured.
Historical answer: NOT_ANSWERED
result bfa3c482d7114e2d · regenerate with npm run diary:experiment